Electronic Frontiers Australia Inc. Media Release July 7th 1996 ELECTRONIC FRONTIERS WELCOMES INTERNET REGULATION REPORT Electronic Frontiers Australia Inc. has welcomed the Australian Broadcasting Authority report on Internet regulation. "In strongly endorsing PICS, the Platform for Internet Content Selection, and recommending a community education campaign, the ABA has demonstrated its grasp of the complex technical and moral issues involved", said EFA spokesperson Irene Graham today. EFA commended the ABA for its consultation with industry representatives and Internet users and for making the report publicly available on the Internet. "The ABA's approach is in stark contrast to that of most State Attorneys General", said Graham. "EFA is delighted that the ABA has endorsed the PICS initiative. We strongly support PICS and similar international rating systems", Graham said. "These technologies provide the most effective means for controlling children's access to material on the world-wide Internet and assign responsibility for content selection where it belongs - under the control of the end user, or in the case of children, with parents and teachers." The report also places welcome emphasis on an educational strategy to inform users about the technological resources available to protect themselves and their children from controversial material. "A community education campaign has been proposed in every government on-line regulation report since the 1994 BBS Task Force Report. However we have yet to see it eventuate", said Graham. "We hope that the ABA's recommendation in this regard will be acted upon immediately. An equally important part of an education campaign is the need to allay community concerns resulting from sensationalist portrayal of the Internet - an image rejected by the ABA's finding that the likelihood of users being involuntarily exposed to objectionable material is negligible." "There are a number of other positive initiatives in the report, however there are also a number of inconsistencies and failures. The report is clearly intended to appease a diversity of interests", Graham said. "EFA's primary concern continues to be the so-called 'model criminal offence provisions'. The biggest problem is that some ABA recommendations support State censorship legislation rather than being an alternative to it", said Graham. "The report advocates self-regulation, yet at the same time suggests that the most important role of ABA approved Codes of Conduct would be to provide defences to criminal offences. While the ABA generally acknowledges adults' rights to freedom of expression, Attorneys General seem to want the Net to be a children's playground. The grave inconsistencies between the ABA approach and those of the Attorneys General make it imperative that the Attorneys General, at their meeting this week, scrap existing proposals and re-focus on developing a consistent national policy based on the findings of the ABA inquiry." "Although the ABA has diplomatically fallen short of criticising the proposals of the Attorneys General, we are heartened that the Minister for Communications and the Arts, Senator Alston, in announcing the release of the report on Friday, made several comments implying that the current actions by the States are inappropriate", said Graham. "The report also fails to address what is, for EFA, a central concern. On the Internet any individual can publish material. Codes of practice and complaints mechanisms may be reasonable for commercial service providers and content creators, but ordinary users are likely to find them unduly burdensome. The ABA report appears to leave these people at the mercy of draconian laws such as the NSW proposed national model. Further development of a new approach is needed to ensure that ordinary individuals, provided with unprecedented opportunities to express an opinion and obtain information, do not become criminals simply because they misunderstand complex classification regimes and inadequately defined laws, or receive unsolicited material." "Whilst the ABA report is a major step forward, it leaves many questions unanswered and many problems unresolved." ENDS. -------------------------------------------------------------- Electronic Frontiers Australia Inc -- http://www.efa.org.au/ representing Internet users concerned with on-line freedoms -------------------------------------------------------------- Background: the full text of the ABA report is available at: http://www.dca.gov.au/aba/olsrprt.htm